October 15, 2026
Bald Head Island's Village Council met in a special session on September 23, 2026. It decided not to spend $130,000 on a feasibility study for turning the island's 13 soft tube groins into hardened structures. Instead, the Council will keep replacing the geotextile tubes about every six years, as it already does, "unless new information emerges." The Village's written recap of that meeting puts the reasoning in a few short paragraphs. Read with the Village's own shoreline records, those paragraphs settle what the long tan tubes crossing the west end of South Beach are for. They are a recurring line item that the Village has chosen to keep paying.
The tubes sit on the western end of South Beach, just east of the island's terminal groin. North Carolina's Division of Coastal Management says the field was first installed in 1996, under a variance from the Coastal Resources Commission's rules and alongside a beach fill project, and was replaced with newer sand-filled tubes in 2005. The first version had sixteen tubes. The Village has had to correct the record on location at least once. In June 2024, its newsletter pointed out that a press article had placed the sand tubes on the east end of South Beach, which was wrong.
The location follows from the erosion. The Village's coastal engineers describe chronic erosion on the west end that they link to the Wilmington Harbor shipping channel. In a 2024 presentation to state officials, the Village said accelerated erosion near the channel had threatened infrastructure and the beach itself. It described the tube field as support for the terminal groin, slowing sand as it moves along the shore and shoals toward the navigation channel.
The terminal groin is the big structure. Island property owners built it for about $6 million, and it was finished in 2015 or 2016, depending on which Village document you read. It took special legislation in 2011 to allow it. The tubes are the smaller tool on the downdrift side. They are soft, sand-filled, and made to wear out.
State coastal law limits what can be built on an ocean shoreline. It generally bars permanent erosion-control structures, allows temporary structures only in the form of sandbags, and sets out a separate permitting path for terminal groins. The tube field works within those limits, and the fabric wears out on schedule. Village engineers reported in September 2024 that several tubes had degraded or failed. They said all 13 had reached the end of their useful life and needed replacing after the next nourishment.
The record of replacements so far:
| Period | What happened | Cost reported |
|---|---|---|
| March 1996 | Sixteen soft groins built of geotextile and sand fill | Not found in records reviewed |
| January to March 2005 | 1996 field replaced, with minor changes to groin locations | Not found in records reviewed |
| 2009 | Field fully rehabilitated, with some groin lengths adjusted | Not found in records reviewed |
| 2018–2019 | All 13 tubes replaced alongside a Village-funded beach nourishment | $1.0 million for the tubes; $10.9 million for the nourishment |
| September 2024 | Engineers report several tubes degraded or failed | n/a |
| January 5 to February 2025 | McPherson Marine Services replaces all 13 tubes during the 2025 CSDR project | Not reported separately from the larger project |
| Around 2031 | Next replacement, if the six-year cycle holds | Not yet estimated |
Two of the dates need a word of explanation. The 2025 CSDR project page says the contractor finished the tubes on February 16, 2025, while the engineers' monitoring report gives February 17. The 2031 date is simple arithmetic: the 2025 replacement plus the six-year cycle the Council has just reaffirmed. The Village has not announced it. The cycle has also drifted a little. In June 2024, the Village described the tubes as needing replacement "every 5 years or so." The full replacements on record fall six years apart, in 2019 and 2025.
Each of the last two replacements also came alongside a large sand placement on South Beach. During the 2025 work, one Village update reported that tube 15 was "100% exposed." That was the contractor digging it out for removal, not storm damage. Anyone who walked the beach that winter saw the field taken apart and rebuilt.
Converting the field to hardened structures is an old idea. In 2024, the Village said its coastal engineer had been proposing rock structures in place of the soft tube groins for about five years, so that the tubes would no longer have to be maintained and replaced.
At the September meeting, staff put a price on it. Hardening all 13 groins at full length would cost about $11.34 million. If some groins turned out to be unnecessary or could be shorter, the cost might come down to around $8 million. Only a feasibility study could tell which, and that study would cost $130,000.
Compare those figures with the last tube replacement whose cost was published, $1.0 million in 2018–19.
This is rough math. It does not adjust for inflation, it uses a tube price that is now more than six years old, and the Village has not published it. The Village's materials do not list a separate price for the 2025 tube work, so no current per-cycle figure is public. Even so, the gap is big enough that a fair amount of price growth in tube work would not close it.
According to the recap, the Council majority concluded that with the conversion expected to cost $10 million to $13 million or more, the Village probably would not go ahead even after a study. That made spending $130,000 on one hard to justify. Several members also said earlier proposals had not made clear what the study would actually produce, and they wanted defined scope, cost projections and comparisons of alternatives first.
Time is a cost too. In its 2024 discussion of a possible hardened structure at the east end of South Beach, the Village set out what any such project would involve. That meant at least 24 months of shoreline modeling and a federal environmental review under NEPA, with an environmental impact study, of 18 to 24 months, including public scoping and comment periods. It also meant roughly 150 days of Corps and state CAMA permitting, with review by state and federal agencies covering marine fisheries, water quality, sea turtles and wildlife. Financing could require a general obligation bond and a referendum. The Village estimated that, as with the terminal groin, getting from legislation to completion would take at least five years. Its coastal engineer called permit feasibility for converting the tube field "questionable" under North Carolina law as it stood.
Put the money and the calendar together and the decision follows. A hardened field would cost several times a tube replacement, and it would need years of review and an uncertain permit before any rock reached the beach. The tubes can be replaced with a contractor and a winter work window. The Council's recap says the tube program stays in place unless tube technology or costs change in a major way.
The decision mostly confirms what is already on the west end of South Beach.
The tubes are a fixed part of the beach for the foreseeable future. Replacement work comes in clusters, and the last two rounds lined up with large sand placements. The next one, if the cycle holds, falls around 2031.
The tube field and the terminal groin work together. The Village's project page describes sand placed from the terminal groin eastward through the tube field. The tubes help hold sand that the groin and the nourishment projects put there.
The water off the west end deserves extra caution. The Village's beach safety page urges care near the west end of South Beach, close to the shipping channel, because passing ships can stir up dangerous water movement. The page says nothing specific about walking on the tubes.
The Village watches the structures around storms. According to its shoreline protection page, the Village assesses shoreline stabilization structures before major storms, compares conditions afterward, and brings in engineers and surveyors when there is a significant change. The engineers' yearly findings are posted with the Village's monitoring reports. The most recent report reviewed for this post, dated November 2025, covers the 2025 tube replacement. We found no report of storm damage to the new tubes since then.
The Council also discussed the wider sand picture that day. The Army Corps of Engineers told the Village it hopes to finish re-evaluating the Sand Management Plan by about midsummer 2027 and will give monthly updates until then. The Village asked the Corps to keep a West Beach erosion hot spot in mind for its 2027–2028 channel maintenance dredging. The Council's next regular meeting is Friday, October 23, 2026, at 10 a.m. in the multi-purpose room at the Department of Public Safety, and remote listeners can join by Zoom.
Long-term shoreline costs on a barrier island show up in Village budgets, nourishment cycles and ownership plans. Please reach out to Barbara Adams if you'd like to go through how programs like the tube field fit into owning on Bald Head Island, for a family property now or a decision ahead. Schedule a confidential consultation.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.
I am committed to guiding you every step of the way—whether you're buying a home, selling a property, or securing a mortgage. Whatever your needs, I've got you covered.