Elevated blue-gray shingle cottage with wraparound porches, wood pilings, and a live oak canopy.

How One Chef Connects Two Bald Head Island Restaurants

September 17, 2026

"We've been over there 40 years, and this will make seven small mom-and-pop businesses Plunkett and I created and managed over the years, so this is probably our last project." Harper Peterson told WilmingtonBiz in 2022.

He was discussing the two spots he and his wife Plunkett had just opened inside the island's former police station. He was wrong about it being his last project, as it turned out, but he wasn't exaggerating the number. If you've eaten breakfast at Sandpiper, ordered a margarita at Delphina, grabbed a coffee at Midway, or settled into a burger at Jailhouse Provisions, you've spent money in the same small business family more times than you probably realized.

Bald Head Island has a year-round population of roughly 300 people. It is not a place with room for a crowded restaurant scene built by dozens of independent operators. What it has instead is something more interesting: a food and rental economy where most of the names on the door trace back to one couple who started with a bicycle rental stand in 1983, plus a newer cluster of businesses that arrived without any connection to that original family at all. Knowing which lineage you're eating in changes how you read the island's next few years of growth.

The Bike Stand at the Old Inn

The story starts at the invitation of the Mitchell family, the developers who platted Bald Head Island starting in the early 1980s. Harper Peterson set up a weekend bicycle rental program at the old Bald Head Inn. By 1984 he'd added canoes and golf carts. By 1985 he and Plunkett had opened their first retail shop at what is still the Riverside location today.

From there the pair kept adding pieces. The Sail Shop came in 2010. Maritime Passage dates to 2001. Canopy Outfitters opened in 2007. For years the couple also ran Island Passage, a small chain of women's clothing boutiques that eventually stretched into Wilmington and Lumina Station, though they sold those locations in 2014 and kept the original Bald Head store, renamed Riverside Adventure Company.

The food side of the business arrived in 2013, when the Petersons converted the former River Pilot Café at the marina into Delphina, a Latin American cantina. They hired Carlos Rojas, a chef whose family heritage runs through Cuba, Spain, and Mexico, and who had previously worked at Lumina Station's Brasserie and as a sous chef at the Bald Head Island Club. Sandpiper Coffee and Ice Cream opened around the same time, a few doors down.

One Kitchen, More Than One Storefront

Here's the detail that turns a list of businesses into something worth knowing. When the Petersons opened Jailhouse Provisions in late 2021, inside the island's former Village Police Station on Edward Teach Extension, they didn't hire a new chef to run the kitchen. Carlos Rojas, the same executive chef who built Delphina's menu, has been credited as running the kitchen at Jailhouse Provisions too. Two restaurants with different names, different menus on paper, and a shared cook turning out the food.

That's not a criticism. It's a useful thing to understand if you've ever wondered why the island's dining options, spread across a handful of buildings, can feel like variations on a theme rather than truly distinct kitchens. In a market this small, one good chef working across a couple of dining rooms is efficient, and it's also a sign of how concentrated the ownership actually is.

As of today, the Peterson-Dodge portfolio on the island includes:

  • Riverside Adventure Company, the original bike, cart, and gear rental shop
  • The Sail Shop
  • Delphina Coastal Cuisine, the Latin American cantina at the marina
  • Sandpiper Coffee and Ice Cream
  • Midway Coffee BHI
  • Jailhouse Provisions, the restaurant and bar in the former police station

Peterson framed the coffee shop and Jailhouse Provisions as a response to a real gap. Bald Head, he told WilmingtonBiz at the time, is an incredible resort destination for families, but it needed more food and beverage options, especially as the island's workforce became more of a year-round presence rather than a purely seasonal one.

The Founding Family Is Stepping Back

That expansion didn't happen in a vacuum. A mid-2025 WilmingtonBiz report on the island's commercial future describes Peterson as one of the "stewards" that Bald Head Island Limited, the Mitchell family's development company, has been transitioning legacy assets to as it winds down its own remaining island businesses. BHI Ltd. has been the island's master developer since the early 1980s, and the same report notes it continues to divest what it still owns as it hands the island's next chapter to people like the Petersons.

That handoff has been happening alongside a slower, more contentious process: the village's commercial area master planning effort, which started in 2022 with the planning firm ColeJenest & Stone. A public survey of 224 full-time residents flagged landscaping, environmental preservation, more food options, and green space as top priorities. The village put a moratorium on new commercial construction in June 2022 to give the planning process room to work, and didn't lift it until November 2023. An earlier draft of that plan floated ideas like a two-story golf cart barn near the ferry landing and a welcome center, framed as ways to separate pedestrians from vehicle traffic in the marina area as the island grows.

A Different Kind of Opening, Down Merchants Row

While the Peterson family's businesses represent four decades of slow, related growth, a separate cluster has been building on the other side of the island with no connection to any of it. Stoked Village, at Merchants Row, opened its restaurant Cozumel, an upscale Mexican concept, in July 2025. The development also includes Blue Sail, a gift and apparel shop, and Stoked Provisions, which runs fishing charters and outdoor excursions.

Then, in April, the island approved its first arcade. Stoked Village Arcade, at 5 Merchants Row, had actually opened back in March, before the operator realized a special use permit was required and had to go through a hearing to keep running. It's registered to Bald Head Island Plaza LLC, overseen by Jeff Stokely Jr., a former New Hanover County planning board member. Stokely told the island's planning board the goal was simple: give kids somewhere to go after a day at the beach, while parents shop or eat nearby.

Two commercial clusters, two very different origin stories. One grew out of a family that has been physically present on the island since before most of its current homes existed. The other is a newer development with a different set of owners. That wider public interest in food options forms part of the backdrop to both clusters.

What This Actually Means for Anyone Who Eats Here

None of this is a ranking of one over the other. It's context. The next time a new restaurant sign goes up on Bald Head Island, the useful question isn't just what's on the menu. It's whether you're looking at another branch of a business relationship that started with a bike rental stand in 1983, or at something built by a newer group of owners. Both are shaping what "island dining" means here as the village works through what its next stretch of commercial growth is allowed to look like.

If you've noticed the island's food scene changing shape over the past year, that's not your imagination. It's two different lineages growing at the same time, on an island small enough that you can taste the difference if you know to look for it.

If you're thinking about a longer-term move to Bald Head Island, whether that's a first purchase, a downsizing decision, or settling a family estate, the island's business history is part of the texture worth understanding before you buy. Barbara Bayles Adams works with buyers and sellers who want that kind of ground-level familiarity with the place, not just a list of comparable sales. Schedule a confidential consultation when you're ready to talk specifics.

Work With Barbara

I am committed to guiding you every step of the way—whether you're buying a home, selling a property, or securing a mortgage. Whatever your needs, I've got you covered.